Infosheet
Expert Evaluators - Background & How to become an evaluator
Who are those people that evaluate the proposals? What background do they have? What instructions do they get? And how can you become an evaluator yourself?
Published on | 3 years ago
Last updated on | 8 months ago
sarah.stroobants@fwo.be
Expert evaluators' role
The European Union Institutions appoint external experts to assist in the evaluation of grant applications, projects and tenders, and to provide opinions and advice in specific cases.
In particular, experts assist in:
- Evaluation of proposals, prize applications and tenders
- Monitoring of actions, grant agreements, public procurement contracts
In addition, experts also can provide advice on the preparation, implementation and evaluation of EU programmes and design of policies.
Become an expert evaluator
As the evaluators are regularly rotated, the Commission is always looking for new candidates to join the 'pool of experts'. With respect to evaluations in particular, for each call, at least 25% of experts included in the 'pool' should be newcomers. Think you've got relevant skills? Find out below how to get started.
Profile
The Commission is looking for professionals in various fields and with varied skillsets to help evaluate EU projects. The evaluation panels are composed of experts with diverse backgrounds and from various sectors:
- Universities / higher education institutions and research organisations
- Industry, business associations and innovation agencies
- Non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and other civil society organisations
- Local, regional and national administration
- International organisations
The Commission strives to achieve gender equality and strongly encourages female experts to register.
What is in it for me?
- You gain insights into the evaluation process and criteria of proposals for EU funding programmes, which will be useful when engaging in future projects proposals in European funding programmes
- You gain insight into the state of the art in your field in a European context
- It is an opportunity to engage in European services that support recognition of your expertise at EU level
Practicalities
Find out more about what to expect as an expert evaluator in the open call for experts published by the Commission. This call for expression details the selection criteria, the required expertise, the description of the tasks, their duration and the conditions for remuneration. More information on practicalities can also be found in the model contract for experts.
Get started!
- Register in the Commission's expert database. The most suitable candidates are selected.
- List all relevant keywords that best describe your expertise (use the terminology of EU funding programmes).
- If selected you will be contracted from 2 days up to 2 weeks spread over several months.
- You will conduct the majority of your work remotely.
Can I still participate in EU funding programmes as a registered evaluator?
Expert evaluators are certainly allowed to submit project proposals themselves. However, as an evaluator, you may not assess your own project proposals, nor project proposals from colleagues working for the same employer or project proposals within a call for which you have submitted yourself.
What instructions do expert evaluators get?
Besides some information on the background of the call topics, there is for the Horizon Europe expert evaluators the standard briefing for experts (also attached to this infosheet). This presentation contains the following topics:
- Evaluation procedure (including the evaluation criteria per type of action)
- How to evaluate proposals (individual evaluation, how to deal with the criteria etc.)
- Role of the independent experts (guiding principles, confidentiality, conflicts of interests)
Even if you're not considering to become an expert, it's still worthwhile to spend 15 to 30 minutes to go through these slides. It allows you to be up-to-date on the mindset with which your proposal will be evaluated.
Who are the expert evaluators?
The European Commission publishes anually (with some delay) the whole list of experts. For the framework programme for research and innovation, the current list covers the period 2014-2018, and is divided into H2020 pillars, thematic areas and the country of evaluator's origin. You can browse this list here.
For further information, we refer to the "work as an expert" page on the F&T portal and the dedicated page on the Commission's website.
myOVERVIEW
-
sign up for personalised information
We offer news and event updates, covering all domains and topics of Horizon Europe, Digital Europe & EDF (and occasionally, for ongoing projects, Horizon 2020).
Stay informed about what matters to you.
By signing up, you can opt in for e-mail notifications and get access to
a personalised dashboard that groups all news updates and event announcements in your domain(s).
Only for stakeholders located in Flanders
Testimonial
Autoship - a new and durable way of freight transport
Autoship is, as the name suggests, an acronym for autonomous ship. Just like with self-driving cars, the possibilities of an unmanned boat seem endless. It can create more efficient freight transport, around the clock deliveries and these are just a few of the examples. The project has two societal challenges.
At first, De Vlaamse Waterweg was a bit hesitant as their experience with FP7 or Horizon 2020 projects was limited and they had not been very successful up until then. The fact that they were already doing basic research on the topic of autonomous boats, and the administrative help of NCP FLanders helped De Vlaamse waterweg to cross the line and get involved.
